Working Group Guidelines for Publishing Proceedings of Workshops or Symposia

TWS working groups often publish proceedings from the symposia or workshops they sponsor at TWS’ Annual Conference and elsewhere. Yet working groups have several different publishing options, such as publishing proceedings in special sections of The Journal of Wildlife Management or the Wildlife Society Bulletin, working with commercial or academic book publishers, or publishing electronically via the internet.

Typically workshops or symposia are organized and chaired by a group of individuals. These individuals select the presenters and provide guidance on content of presentations. Sometimes workshops and symposia are conducted with the aim of publishing proceedings, but sometimes the idea of publishing proceedings comes only after oral presentations.

Regardless of whether a proceedings is part of the initial planning or an afterthought, the published material should undergo more-rigorous scrutiny than the oral presentations. Material published under the TWS logo, including material only available electronically, deserves and requires peer review in keeping with the principles of science-based wildlife management and TWS’ Code of Ethics. The peer review process provides self-regulation of our profession through evaluation by qualified individuals. Peer review methods help maintain TWS standards, and provide credibility to TWS products and sponsored events.

For proceedings published in the Society's scientific journals, strict standards of peer review are well-established, and the journals’ editors-in-chief are required to follow those standards. If a working group decides to publish a proceedings with a TWS journal, the editor-in-chief should be brought into the process at an early stage.

For situations where proceedings are published outside of the TWS journal family, the same rigorous process used by TWS journals must be followed. Therefore, TWS working groups publishing proceedings must follow these guidelines:

  1. Editor(s) of the proceedings to be published will be selected and approved by the governing board of the working group. These editors may be the symposium or workshop organizer(s), although the governing board may decide that other individuals are better qualified to prepare and edit the content of the proceedings. In general, editor(s) should be members of the working group, and thus TWS members, although exceptions may be made by the working group governing board.
  2. At least two wildlife professionals (preferably members of TWS) will peer review each of the papers that are published. Anonymous peer review is preferred, although compliance will sometimes be difficult to achieve for specialized topics. The editor(s) of the proceedings will select the reviewers.
  3. The editor(s) of the proceedings will evaluate the resulting reviews, and determine whether the material should be published in the proceedings. Authors may be asked for revisions of materials based on reviewers' comments. Just because an author presents material during an oral session does not mean that the material will automatically be included in the proceedings. Likewise, an editor may decide to include material that was not presented orally at the symposium, either because the presenter was unable to attend, or because an important topic needs to be included for completeness of the proceedings.
  4. Editors are expected to operate in a fair and ethical manner with authors. Editor(s) will allow authors the opportunity for review and response. If a researcher’s work is specifically criticized by papers to be published in the proceedings, editors should alert the researcher and give that person an opportunity to respond in the same proceedings. If someone attending the symposium takes issue with a presentation and would like to prepare a comment to be published, they should contact the editor, who should also give the author the opportunity for a rebuttal if the editor feels it is warranted. .
  5. Editors must be cognizant of conflicts of interest, including their own. Editors of proceedings should not have a vested interest in one particular side of an issue.
  6. Editors should set limits on the number and amount of paper amendments. If late revisions are allowed, then all authors of published proceedings should be given equal opportunity to make revisions, particularly with point-counterpoint material.
  7. Editors should show authors all changes that have been made to their individual articles, and give authors an opportunity to comment on those changes, prior to publication of their work.
  8. Upon completion of the selection and editing of papers for the proceedings, the editor(s) of the proceedings will provide the materials to the governing board of the working group for final approval.
  9. Published proceedings should carry the disclaimer that papers do not necessarily reflect the views of The Wildlife Society, even though their content may have been presented in whole or in part at a TWS Annual Conference or other TWS-sponsored event. However, such disclaimers should not be viewed as an excuse to publish libelous or shoddy work, and editors and working group governing boards should be held accountable for such work.
  10. All authors and editors of published papers in the proceedings must adhere to the TWS Code of Ethics, regardless of whether they are a member of TWS or not.

TWS Administrative Support

The Wildlife Society staff and Council actively encourage the formation and success of working groups and provide ongoing assistance to them. Administrative support is provided primarily by TWS’ Program Manager of Subunits and Certification. Staff support of working groups consists of, but is not limited to, promoting membership in working groups; collecting annual dues; maintaining membership lists; providing space for working group news and technical information in TWS’ publications and on TWS’ website; fostering meetings, seminars, and other forums for working group members; providing technical assistance with newsletters, other publications, and electronic communications; and other actions as Council or the Executive Director deem appropriate.